2015 Anger General Greatest post-merger Players of All Time #12

[Y2K]

The results are in. Kevin Garnett was voted as the #11 Greatest Post-Merger Player of All Time.

Each thread will be stickied to the general board until the given round is over. Nominations during this round are open.

1. Michael Jordan
2. Tim Duncan
3. Earvin Magic Johnson
4. Larry Bird
5. Shaquille O'Neal
6. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
7. Kobe Bryant
8. Hakeem Olajuwon
9. Lebron James
10. Moses Malone
11. Kevin Garnett

Begin by casting your vote for #12 from these candidates:


Dirk Nowitzki - 4

Dwyane Wade - 2

Karl Malone - 1

David Robinson - 5


Total Votes: 12

[Havlicekstealsit]

[gaskill15]

Barry Pepper is not an option!

[Y2K]

What are thoughts and analysis on Dirk?

[PhutureDynasty]

Wade.

[ripper76]

Wade

[americaninfidel]

I was going to go Wade again, but I think DRob actually has a slight edge.

Robinson:

2x Champion

10x All-Star

Rookie of the Year
1xDPOY
1xMVP

4x 1st team All-NBA
2x 2nd team All-NBA
4x 3rd team All-NBA

4x 1st team All-Defensive
4x 2nd team All-Defensive

---------------------------------

Wade:

3x Champion

11x All-Star

1x FMVP

2x 1st team All-NBA
3x 2nd team All-NBA
3x 3rd team All-NBA

3x 2nd team All-Defensive

DRob gets my vote.

[Y2K]

I was going to go Wade again, but I think DRob actually has a slight edge.

Robinson:

2x Champion

10x All-Star

Rookie of the Year
1xDPOY
1xMVP

4x 1st team All-NBA
2x 2nd team All-NBA
4x 3rd team All-NBA

4x 1st team All-Defensive
4x 2nd team All-Defensive

---------------------------------

Wade:

3x Champion

11x All-Star

1x FMVP

2x 1st team All-NBA
3x 2nd team All-NBA
3x 3rd team All-NBA

3x 2nd team All-Defensive

DRob gets my vote.

Wade at his best was easily a top 5 player in the league. He just couldn't stay healthy long enough to string together a very distinctive and impressive peak.

He's adapted his game very well to age and the various physical limitations but I just can't place him over the other 3 candidates.

[dwcmwa]

Malone

[dwcmwa]

What are thoughts and analysis on Dirk?

Dirk is no doubt a great player but he's not better than Malone and Robinson or Isiah and Pippen for that matter.

Oh yeah and Dr. J

[wailuaFC]

Robinson

[876Stephen]

Dirk

[Odogg]

Dirk Diggler

[elmouse03]

I will say D-Rob. Before Duncan arrived he was one of the best players in the league. Scoring champ and mvp.

[dwcmwa]

I nominate Dr. J

[876Stephen]

Is Dirk starting to become underrated?

I mean people are considering a serial playoff underachiever like Malone and David Robinson.

David Robinson's legacy was saved by Tim Duncan. No lie. Those 2 titles he has, no matter how small of a role it was, seriously boost his all time case.

[wailuaFC]

Is Dirk starting to become underrated?

I mean people are considering a serial playoff underachiever like Malone and David Robinson.

David Robinson's legacy was saved by Tim Duncan. No lie. Those 2 titles he has, no matter how small of a role it was, seriously boost his all time case.

Does dirk not get a huge boost for beating the horrible tyrant that is lebron James? I like dirk, he was an awesome offensive player, but Robinson provided so much more defensively along with being a scoring champion

[AlaskaHawks]

Is Dirk starting to become underrated?

I mean people are considering a serial playoff underachiever like Malone and David Robinson.

David Robinson's legacy was saved by Tim Duncan. No lie. Those 2 titles he has, no matter how small of a role it was, seriously boost his all time case.

Does dirk not get a huge boost for beating the horrible tyrant that is lebron James? I like dirk, he was an awesome offensive player, but Robinson provided so much more defensively along with being a scoring champion

Scoring champion*

[elmouse03]

Is Dirk starting to become underrated?

I mean people are considering a serial playoff underachiever like Malone and David Robinson.

David Robinson's legacy was saved by Tim Duncan. No lie. Those 2 titles he has, no matter how small of a role it was, seriously boost his all time case.

Does dirk not get a huge boost for beating the horrible tyrant that is lebron James? I like dirk, he was an awesome offensive player, but Robinson provided so much more defensively along with being a scoring champion

Scoring champion*

because no Jordan?

[AlaskaHawks]

Does dirk not get a huge boost for beating the horrible tyrant that is lebron James? I like dirk, he was an awesome offensive player, but Robinson provided so much more defensively along with being a scoring champion

Scoring champion*

because no Jordan?

No. Because that last game of the season.