I'm not a big Peyton Manning guy, but...

[FPL]

If he wins against this tough Seattle team, how can we keep him out of the top 10 GOAT QBs anymore? Some might say I'm too high on him (and maybe I am), but how does he not sneak into the top 10 if he wins this coming SB?

[jordanzone]

..he's already top 10...

[Sudanese Sensation]

He's definitely top ten, win or lose...

Should he win a good case can be made hes' #1

Also, he appears to be a genuinely good guy...

[Deez]

Easily top 10 with another ring. Pretty much a lock for top 10 the way it stands now. I mean his brother has 2 rings and he's far from being in the top 10.

[Yuh]

Montana
Brady
Marino
Young
Manning
Brees
Favre
Elway
Kelly
Rodgers

He's already Top 10 in my lifetime.

(Not including QBs like Sammy Baugh, Otto Graham, and Johnny Unitas.)

[dunkan5rings]

Easily top 10 with another ring. Pretty much a lock for top 10 the way it stands now. I mean his brother has 2 rings and he's far from being in the top 10.

Eli 2 rings. Eli is better.

[FPL]

..he's already top 10...

I was looking to troll, but my main man ghost town isn't online at the moment.

[zombiesonics]

He's already top 5. He's going for GOAT status.

[jordanzone]

..he's already top 10...

I was looking to troll, but my main man ghost town isn't online at the moment.

well hell...why do I take you so seriously (lol)...

[dunkan5rings]

He's already top 5. He's going for GOAT status.

[jordanzone]

I think the bigger question is:

Do Jim Brown and Barry Sanders deserve to be in the Top 10 greatest runningbacks discussion.

Brown yes, Sanders, no....no one respects a quitter...

[Sudanese Sensation]

Easily top 10 with another ring. Pretty much a lock for top 10 the way it stands now. I mean his brother has 2 rings and he's far from being in the top 10.

Eli 2 rings. Eli is better.

If rings are all that matters then Terry Bradshaw and Joe Montana are co-GOATS and Troy Aikman and Tom Brady are runner up GOATS.

[Deez]

Easily top 10 with another ring. Pretty much a lock for top 10 the way it stands now. I mean his brother has 2 rings and he's far from being in the top 10.

Eli 2 rings. Eli is better.

Nope, not even close.

[Yuh]

I think the bigger question is:

Do Jim Brown and Barry Sanders deserve to be in the Top 10 greatest runningbacks discussion.

Brown yes, Sanders, no....no one respects a quitter...

Your posting privileges should be revoked for this comment.

[AlaskaHawks]

LOL @ Sheli giving Peyton hints about playing at Met Life. He threw 15 picks in 8 games.

[Yuh]

Easily top 10 with another ring. Pretty much a lock for top 10 the way it stands now. I mean his brother has 2 rings and he's far from being in the top 10.

Eli 2 rings. Eli is better.

If rings are all that matters then Terry Bradshaw and Joe Montana are co-GOATS and Troy Aikman and Tom Brady are runner up GOATS.

I'll LMFAO at anyone who says Eli, Aikman, or Bradshaw are better than Marino because of their rings.

[Sudanese Sensation]

I think the bigger question is:

Do Jim Brown and Barry Sanders deserve to be in the Top 10 greatest runningbacks discussion.

Brown yes, Sanders, no....no one respects a quitter...

Your posting privileges should be revoked for this comment.

I think there's a difference between a quitter and a retiree... Also, Jim Brown walked away from the game before his thirtieth birthday...I think that added to his mystique...

[jordanzone]

I think the bigger question is:

Do Jim Brown and Barry Sanders deserve to be in the Top 10 greatest runningbacks discussion.

Brown yes, Sanders, no....no one respects a quitter...

Your posting privileges should be revoked for this comment.

I was playing along with the trolling of the comment I quoted...but in all reality, he did quit...he's top 10, relax...haha

[Deez]

Eli 2 rings. Eli is better.

If rings are all that matters then Terry Bradshaw and Joe Montana are co-GOATS and Troy Aikman and Tom Brady are runner up GOATS.

I'll LMFAO at anyone who says Eli, Aikman, or Bradshaw are better than Marino because of their rings.

In all reality though nobody will ever even mention Eli ever on a list of QB's for top anything.

[wailuaFC]

I think the bigger question is:

Do Jim Brown and Barry Sanders deserve to be in the Top 10 greatest runningbacks discussion.

And where does Bo belong?