2015 Anger General Greatest post-merger Players of All Time #29

[Master Spade]

I agree with Spade and Odogg; none of the options is very compelling, and four is likely too few at this point. I'm inclined to throw a vote to Iverson, but I don't feel strongly about it.

Infidel, the thing about adding more options is that they won't necessarily be better options than what we have on the board.

Maybe not, but at this point, so many players are so close that only having 4 options makes it less accurate. One of the players not listed may of won the vote. So why not expand the selections to ......maybe 8? The more options the better at this point.

With only 4 options, most posters are voting for one of the current options.........just to vote, and not because they actually like the selection. With more options, more posters would like their votes a little more.

I don't see a downside with having more options.

[Deez]

I agree with Spade and Odogg; none of the options is very compelling, and four is likely too few at this point. I'm inclined to throw a vote to Iverson, but I don't feel strongly about it.

Infidel, the thing about adding more options is that they won't necessarily be better options than what we have on the board.

Lets add Bill Walton

lol, knock it off.

[Y2K]

Voting for this round closes at 11 am CST. Eligible candidates are:

Paul Pierce
Dominique Wilkins
Robert Parish


Who else did I miss?

[Robceltsfan]

I nominated Walton too....if that matters.

[Deez]

I nominated Walton too....if that matters.

GTFO

[Robceltsfan]

I nominated Walton too....if that matters.

GTFO

[Deez]

I nominated Walton too....if that matters.

GTFO

I nominate Anthony Davis. Waltons 3 good years aren't as good as Anthony's 3 seasons thus far. Peak

[Robceltsfan]

GTFO

I nominate Anthony Davis. Waltons 3 good years aren't as good as Anthony's 3 seasons thus far. Peak

Zero MVPs.....zero Finals MVPs.....zero rings. Not, comparable.

[Deez]

I nominate Anthony Davis. Waltons 3 good years aren't as good as Anthony's 3 seasons thus far. Peak

Zero MVPs.....zero Finals MVPs.....zero rings. Not, comparable.

Stats are better though, higher Win Shares per year offensively and defensively is close. Taking their best 3 years Davis wins.

[elmouse03]

I nominated Walton too....if that matters.

[elmouse03]

Voting for this round closes at 11 am CST. Eligible candidates are:

Paul Pierce
Dominique Wilkins
Robert Parish


Who else did I miss?

Kwame

[Y2K]

I nominated Walton too....if that matters.

It does matter. He's a special case so that's how we are going to treat it. If there is a majority decision to add him to the ballot, then we will add him as well as 2 other candidates.

[Y2K]

The round is officially closed and Chris Paul is the winner. Nominations for candidates to be added to next round's ballot will begin.

1. Vote for TWO candidates

2. Vote for or against Bill Walton's inclusion to the ballot for round 30.


Dominique Wilkins -

Robert Parish - 3

Paul Pierce - 4



Bill Walton
------------

Yes: 2

No:

[AbeVigodaLive]

Pierce and Walton.

[elmouse03]

ugh..

Have to vote for Parish and Pierce to please the Celtic fans

I'll let other people take care of the Walton deal.

[Deez]

Parish and Pierce

[Robceltsfan]

Parish and Pierce.

Yes to Walton.

[Odogg]

Voting for this round closes at 11 am CST. Eligible candidates are:

Paul Pierce
Dominique Wilkins
Robert Parish


Who else did I miss?

Gasol, who should clearly be on there if Parish is, if not sooner.

[Odogg]

Why does OP keep ignoring my nominations, while accepting Boston Robs nominations for Celtics?

[Odogg]

Rob getting "superstar" treatment from the refs apparently.